Mine is holding up good. I followed your lead; sanded, sanded, sanded, degreased, degreased, degreased-painted. I do not carry this particular gun but have done some "scratch" tests and it seems to be holding up well. I would much rather have this than a s****Y ceracoke job. At least you can sand this off and start over. I have a pistol with a s****Y ceracoke job. Trust me, $8-10 bucks for a can of this stuff is well worth it. Taking your chances with all of the ceracoke "experts" out there these days is your own choice. As for me, the guy that did my SA Range Officer, should be shot with it.