Do you have a plan or goal you are working towards for SHTF scenarios? Are you of the opinion less is more? Or do you stock all of the surplus you can get your hands on? What is your long arm to side arm ratio? Does anyone have a caliber consolidation plan or is it anything goes?
I myself am of the opinion that there can be a healthy mix of both. I try to keep a few surplus rifles, nagants, because the ammo is cheap and readily available. Surplus bolt rifles can be excellent hunting rifles as well as proven man stoppers. Modern firearms are a bit more intricate to maintain in the long run, but I feel they are necessary to a well rounded preparation.
I myself am of the opinion that there can be a healthy mix of both. I try to keep a few surplus rifles, nagants, because the ammo is cheap and readily available. Surplus bolt rifles can be excellent hunting rifles as well as proven man stoppers. Modern firearms are a bit more intricate to maintain in the long run, but I feel they are necessary to a well rounded preparation.