Handgun Trade X for Y: OPINIONS NEEDED!

[Dynamis]

I have an H&K P2000 V2 here for sale and I get a trade offer for an XDM. I respond saying sure, I would like to have the XDM if you would like to sweeten the post by $150 to offset the value difference.

I was counter offered with a suggestion that my P2000 is only worth $575 and his XDM is worth $525-$550. Considering the XDM is $550 brand new and the P2000 is $850ish brand new, I thought what I was asking for was more than fair. No hard feelings were exchanged and that was that. It got me thinking.

What does the ODT say?

 

[Dynamis]

Meant to put in General Discussion, so I moved it.

 

[CZ82man]

Sounds very fair to me.

 

[kelleyga36]

A gun or anything for that matter is only worth what someone is willing to pay.

 

[hbrad3]

That sounds about right to me. I've seen the H&Ks go for $700 used and the XDMs for $450. I would say asking for an additional $150 is more than reasonable.
Just my opinion.

 

[STONEWALL]

Fair to me.

That sounds about right to me. I've seen the H&Ks go for $700 used and the XDMs for $450. I would say asking for an additional $150 is more than reasonable.
Just my opinion.

I have not seen a XDm for 450.00

 

[Dynamis]

I paid 475 cash for one in March.

 

[Firewall]

Sounds reasonable. Some are just full of it. Had a trade offer once where a guy was valuing his gun at bass pro prices + tax yet my run wasnt worth 50% of what the average price a used one went for on gunbroker

 

[Dynamis]

Just trying to make sure I wasn't "ripping" the guy off as he led me to believe I may have been doing (even though he didn't come out and say it).

 

[hbrad3]

Fair to me.




I have not seen a XDm for 450.00

Maybe I'm thinkin XD not XDM. Swear I saw one on here but I went back looking and didn't see it. Still, even at $500 he's still $200 apart.