Same buck?

[24on48hunting]

Is this the same buck? Pic of him alive is last October, in the exact same area that I shot him today.
There are some similarities, and also some differences. The white on his muzzle is a spot on match.

 

[BIKER13]

I dont think same deer

 

[Greybeard2]

I’d say different as well.

 

[bigboy851]

I agree with Biker 13 not same deer.

 

[basstracker89]

Either way, good deer

 

[bigboy851]

Either way, good deer

Amen Brother!

 

[mfoster]

Mark I look for body and face scares around neck and top of shoulders,cut ears ,notch in ears .most will have genetically the same brow tines.look at black on legs.i don’t think it is from what I see in pics.

 

[fattboyzz]

No

 

[TheGman]

Is this the same buck? Pic of him alive is last October, in the exact same area that I shot him today.
There are some similarities, and also some differences. The white on his muzzle is a spot on match.
View attachment 6442761View attachment 6442762

Great deer nonetheless

 

[24on48hunting]

I appreciate it fellas. We had that other buck on cam through the season last year, then he disappeared and hasn’t resurfaced. The 9 point I shot on 11/6 has not been seen in person or on cam prior to me killing him. That happens every year for us though. The rut brings bucks in that we never knew existed.
I found it interesting that he had the same travel patterns.
We don’t have enough pics for anything other than minor antler similarities and the white stripe on his muzzle looking similar.