I will report back to this thread if I have similar experience youbask about with the positive "snap" in holstering. I too prefer that positive click and ordered an onyx today. I should receive it in time to decide to keep it or the alien gear 3.0 and return the other I dont like as much. I have been reading more and watching more about this onyx and look forward to trying it myself after hearing your experiences and youtube videos. I am very active and this may be "the one" haha
I am interested to hear what your experience is. Still loving mine so far.