Deer challenge?

[Adamjen15]

I have been tossing around the idea for awhile now. Doing a deer challenge that was like the turkey challenge we did. $20 buy in, what are y’all s thoughts about it? I was thinking a buck would get a certain amount of points and if it scores 110 or better it would get extra points, 130 or better extra points and so on. Let me know what y’all think

 

[kc30121]

$10 entry.3 categories bow, primitive weapon, gun. Largest buck wins that category.

How is the “biggest” buck determined? What about public land vs primate property? There is lots of variables when it comes to managing whitetails.

 

[Adamjen15]

$10 entry.3 categories bow, primitive weapon, gun. Largest buck wins that category.

I like that idea but I just wanted to make it more fair, because a 130 inch buck in Bartow county is an absolute giant. But that same buck in South Georgia is just big

 

[Stuckon22]

Multi state? I go to Kentucky every year for a week and hunt my own private land. One entry or more than one? Neat idea.

 

[Stuckon22]

My private land is in Ga.

 

[Psilloh1]

How is the “biggest” buck determined? What about public land vs primate property? There is lots of variables when it comes to managing whitetails.

Then create individual categories? The deer don’t know if they are on private or public land?....

 

[Adamjen15]

Multi state? I go to Kentucky every year for a week and hunt my own private land. One entry or more than one? Neat idea.

I was thinking of just keeping it in Georgia

 

[Stuckon22]

I was thinking of just keeping it in Georgia

Ok.

 

[kc30121]

I know the deer don’t know the difference between private and public but some people heavily manage there own land and have some really really nice deer on them. I know there is a big difference in deer on my land in cave springs vs South Georgia deer. Not sure how to make this challenge fair.

 

[Stuckon22]

Fair would be biggest wins IMHO. Some land is bigger, holds more animals and regions vary. I have only 25 acres but wouldn't feel bad if someone with 2500 and managed property wins. Be great to see everyone's entries.