Yep, I think you are good on your end. He did have someone offer a higher price than what y'all originally agreed to after the deal was made with you. I will update your feedback.
The list also shows how well the feedback system can work. "most" of the members with a high number of negs (craigs listers) usually leaves the site when no one will deal with them. Most haven't been seen in a few years.
@Okuma Steve . We will take a look. I am not sure if Os knows about this issue, it doesn't work for me either . Thanks for bringing it to out attention.