Definitely DO NOT use the Blackhawk/Redhawk-only loads in the Models 25-5 & 625! You would "Loosen Up" a good Gun in short order...
Having said that, a few years ago Brian Pearce did an article in "Handloader" Magazine about this very subject--IIRC, he showed three different loads levels in...
Don't have THAT Manual, however...Lyman's "Pistol and Revolver Handbook", Third Edition, shows NO Data with either Win 231 OR HP38 & 147-gr. Boolits...FWIW, the ONLY 147-grainer they list is a CAST one...HTH....mikey357
Yeah, what little I know about the "Heavyweights" in 9mm, I think I'd use HS-6...It's a nice-behavin' Powder, not too "Temperature Sensitive", unlike Blue Dot--Plus, Blue Dot seems awfully LOUD to me! YMMV, of course... :) ....HTH....mikey357
Just checked my 2009 Hodgdon Manual...They show NO DATA for Win 231 OR HP38 with ANY 147-gr. projo. in 9mm Para...They DO, however, show some Data with those Powders in .38 Super, FWIW...HTH....mikey357
I am assuming you are looking for Load Data for 9mm Para.? If so, my Fourth Edition of the Hornady Manual shows NO Data using Win. 231 OR HP38 with 147-gr. projectiles...I'll check my Hodgdon Manual when I have a chance...HTH....mikey357